Why I don't wave the American Flag

Why I don't wave the American Flag

True democracy has all but vanished in six decades of American-led warfare

By John Grula 11/21/2012

Like it? Tweet it! SHARE IT!

There are a lot of people waving the American flag these days, but I’m not one of them. I also object to the much-vaunted myth of “American exceptionalism” currently in the Zeitgeist. Here’s why:

I won’t dwell on our enslavement of Africans for more than 200 years and the bloody Civil War (recently estimated to have had a death toll of about 750,000, according to The New York Times) it took to end America’s slavery horrors. The racist Jim Crow policies and segregation that followed the Civil War have by no means been totally extinguished.  

I also won’t dwell on our genocide against the Native Americans, in which we took over a continent by force while wiping out entire cultures. Many of the remnant populations now live in poverty and a state of social disintegration on remote reservations.

However, I will point out that during the 20th century, we became the world’s dominant empire and sought to consolidate our power by staging CIA-backed coup d’états to overthrow democratically elected leaders that our national security state decided it did not like. Examples include Iran’s Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh in 1953 and Chile’s President Salvador Allende in 1973.  

Our national security state has also supported brutal dictators and strongmen who have murdered and violated the human rights of many of their own people. Two glaring examples among many are Fulgencio Batista in Cuba during the 1950s and Roberto d’Aubuisson in El Salvador during the 1980s.

To defend its far-flung empire, US military spending is currently almost twice as much as the combined military budgets of China, Russia, the United Kingdom and France.  According to Republican Congressman and former presidential candidate Ron Paul, the US has military personnel in 130 nations and 900 overseas bases. An official Pentagon report, “Base Structure Report, Fiscal 2010 Baseline,” indicates that Mr. Paul’s numbers are pretty accurate. Paul has also pointed out, rightfully, that bloated military outlays are one of the main causes of our federal government’s budget deficits.

Since the end of World War II, the US has waged six major wars against and/or invasions of other nations, including the Korean War (1950-53), the Vietnam War (1965-1973), the 1989 invasion of Panama, the Persian Gulf War (1990-91), the Iraq War (2003-11) and the Afghanistan War, which started in 2001 and continues to this day.

These wars, the benefits of which have been murky, at best, have resulted in the deaths of well over 100,000 Americans and millions of non-Americans. During the Vietnam War alone, 58,220 US service members and an estimated 2 million Vietnamese soldiers and civilians were killed.  

The Vietnam War was exceptionally brutal, immoral, stupid and totally unnecessary.  Among the crimes committed during this war was the spraying by the US of Agent Orange, an herbicide dropped from the sky to destroy huge swaths of Vietnam’s forests and deny cover to Viet Cong fighters and North Vietnamese troops.

Agent Orange is contaminated with an especially toxic form of dioxin, which has been linked to cancers, birth defects and other diseases in Vietnam as well as in American soldiers who came into contact with it. About two-dozen former American sites in Vietnam are still highly polluted with Agent Orange.

Two other Southeast Asian nations that got sucked into the vortex of the Vietnam War are Laos and Cambodia, which share borders with Vietnam. Hundreds of thousands of Laotians and Cambodians were killed during the Vietnam War, primarily because of secret aerial bombardments by the US.

In Cambodia, the US bombings created tremendous stress and political instability and are part of the reason why Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge came to power and the killing fields of the 1970s ensued.

In Laos, between 1964 and 1973, approximately 580,000 US bombing runs dropped more than 2 million tons of bombs on a country the size of Minnesota.

Since the Vietnam War and the bombings ended, about 20,000 Laotians have been killed or maimed by unexploded US ordinance, and an estimated one-third of Laos is still littered with 80 million unexploded cluster bombs.

The list of US atrocities recounted here is by no means exhaustive, and because they are fresher in Americans’ minds and space is limited, the horrors of the more recent Afghanistan and Iraq Wars will have to be cataloged another day.

If people still want to wave an American flag after reading this, that’s their prerogative. Just don’t expect me to follow suit. As Chalmers Johnson pointed out in his 2004 book, “The Sorrows of Empire,” during the last six decades, we have forsaken the great democratic principles upon which our nation was founded and our imperialist overreach has trampled the human rights of many other peoples.

John Grula, PhD, is affiliated with the Southern California Federation of Scientists.

DIGG | del.icio.us | REDDIT

Like it? Tweet it!

Other Stories by John Grula

Related Articles


Hey! But we (still) got the best basketball players in the world ... oh say can you seeeeeeeeeee ~


posted by DanD on 11/22/12 @ 08:53 p.m.

Dr. John Grula is correct; I cannot contest the numbers of casualties or dates of historical events in his guest opinion piece. The American flag he chooses not to wave in the federal flag of war. Once upon a time until the early 20th. century, with the same design, but reversed colors there was also a federal flag of piece and this was rather common knowledge. I am not certain what “true democracy” is, but it is not mentioned in the national Constitution and Franklin said we had “A republic, if you can keep it.” Washington warned of 'foreign entanglements'. Old Hickory said some worthwhile words in his farewell address as well.
Not all Jim Crow was Southern, as often touted, but had northern backing with a Southern face and very likely European connections as well. John Perkins (author of Confessions of An Economic Hitman) or Gen. Smedley Butlter’s The War Racket tell part of the story of “coup d’etats to overthrow democratically elected leaders” but, as far as I know, not the fuller roles of international banking, top churches of Europe, England, and the Dulles Brothers; especially with the Persians and their oil.
For expanding empire one can go to touchstones like the over throwing of Hawaii and the Spanish American War or earlier adventures further back into the 19th century and the decadents of such men and their fraternal and religious affiliations often absent from history and public discussion.
Going back sixty years and war, it is a glaring omission that the United States, since joining the United Nations in 1945, has not had a Secretary of War and that our military has essentially been a bully for the UNTO. Major Arch E. Roberts’ book Victory Denied could clarify this for anyone interested in overseas conflicts from Korea until the 1960s. Now John Kennedy was President during the seminal years and Catholic. Vietnam was mostly Catholic and being challenged by Buddhists. Is it possible this was also a catalyst for interloping in its affairs? As President, Kennedy did not always play the game. He may have forgotten Presidents are only the most powerful hired hands. His spectacular end still serves as the example of what can happen when you forget. In any case the influence, on our actions, from the UN have to be considered. In addition to that, the Golden Triangle of the criminal drug business.
Now it seems the same bully force is also used to bring countries under some form of central banking as well. The face may extensively be American, but not the principles or hidden persuaders, as historian A. Ralph Epperson calls them. So Mr. Grula makes a strong case for not flying the federal flag of war that most likely flies in the name of the United States, United Nations, or some other entity, but not the United States of America.
Terry Wilson


posted by drybonz58 on 12/04/12 @ 12:57 p.m.
Post A Comment

Requires free registration.

(Forgotten your password?")