One more thing ...

One more thing ...

OIR still working on report nearly two years after officer-involved shooting death 

By André Coleman 03/04/2014

Like it? Tweet it! SHARE IT!

Nearly two years since the incident, the Los Angeles County Office of Independent Review has yet to submit a final report on the officer-involved shooting death of 19-year old Kendrec McDade. 

According to Pasadena police Lt. Tracey Ibarra, the department received a copy of the report in draft form some time last month with a request for more information about McDade’s shooting. The OIR has submitted several draft versions, but has yet to issue a final report.

“The Police Department was supplied with a draft for review,” said Ibarra, who declined to say what the report concluded or what other information was being sought. 

“Additionally,” Ibarra said, “they received supplemental information which we have been continually supplying, including recent information in the last couple of weeks.”

McDade was killed March 24, 2012 after Pasadena police Officers Jeffrey Newlen and Mathew Griffin responded to a 911 call made by Oscar Carrillo-Gonzales. Carrillo-Gonzales claimed he was held up at gunpoint by two African-American men while near a taco truck in Northwest Pasadena. Police say the call put the officers on high alert when they chased the unarmed McDade briefly before shooting and killing him on the corner of Orange Grove Boulevard and Sunset Avenue, near his father’s home.
In December 2012, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office ruled the shooting was justified. “The actions of McDade during the pursuit in conjunction with the information known to the officers at the time of the shooting reasonably created a fear of imminent death or serious bodily injury,” Deputy District Attorney. Deborah A. Delport wrote. “Once the officers perceived that McDade posed an apparent lethal threat their response with deadly force was justified.”

In that report, prosecutors said McDade kept his hand in his pants during the pursuit, and inexplicably turned and ran toward the officers at the conclusion of the pursuit, prompting the officers to open fire.

The two officers involved have also been cleared by the department. However, along with OIR, the FBI is also still investigating the incident. 

In addition, McDade’s parents have filed separate federal lawsuits against the city of Pasadena, Pasadena Police Chief Phillip Sanchez, Newlen, Griffin and Carrillo-Gonzales.

Carrillo-Gonzalez later pleaded guilty in Los Angeles County Superior Court to two misdemeanor charges of making false reports to police and to a 911 dispatcher.

Ibarra said she did not know the OIR’s timetable for completion regarding its investigation. OIR Chief Attorney Michael Gennaco did not return calls for comment.

OIR is a civilian oversight group that was created by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors in 2001 to monitor the Sheriff’s Department and provide legal advice to ensure that allegations of misconduct involving deputies are thoroughly and fairly investigated. The group investigates police-related matters when asked to do so by other law enforcement agencies.
“We are hoping with the additional information they requested they can have a more comprehensive analysis,” Ibarra said.  


Like it? Tweet it!

Other Stories by André Coleman

Related Articles


Great. Two years in the making. . . . and still not done. As citizens, we want our money back.

It makes me wonder about those drafts and why they were sent back for "changes". What was in them? Why has it taken this long to make this a story Mr. Coleman?

posted by Paul G on 3/06/14 @ 02:16 p.m.

As members of the press you are asleep at the wheel on this one. Where is the outrage after a young man dies at the hands of the police and you are not asking the Chief of Police, City Manager, and City Council why the report that is supposed to be the thing that makes corrections to possible police policies so such a thing does not reoccur not completed for two years?

Have another drink of your cool-aid.

posted by Paul G on 3/06/14 @ 05:40 p.m.

It is common for the LE gangbanger class to sandbag all investigations into their own murderous conduct at least until most of the limitation statutes have expired. It's their version of saving the taxpayer money.


posted by DanD on 3/07/14 @ 09:42 p.m.

Wow Raul G, it sounds like you had to pull one of your own teeth just to concur with me.

But you've achieved a milestone. In spite of your knee-jerk predilection to ad-hominem deviate away from a rational conclusion, the facts of a matter some times will still fail to escape you.

Apparently, it's happened again, and I do appreciate your spontaneity.


posted by DanD on 3/09/14 @ 09:40 p.m.

to prevent the need for future reports:
a) don't rob people
b) don't run when police tell you to stop
c) keep your hands out of your pants (wearing a belt might help)

posted by True Freedom on 3/11/14 @ 10:22 a.m.

And the oppressive tragedy of this preventative point-of-view is that --whenever confronted by an emotionally arrogant badge-dangler -- we* should always act like pant-wetting peons regardless of how innocent we actually may be?

*the overwhelmingly unarmed general public


posted by DanD on 3/11/14 @ 11:58 p.m.

DanD - you should comply, especially if innocent. You have nothing to gain by not following orders. Oh yes, the anarchist in all of us wants to run, or tell the officer to f-off, but we must be rational, prudent, and SMART. Also, we must be able to see things from the officer's point of view and know that they are often in very dangerous situations.. and they should, as a matter of survival, approach situations expecting the worst. Therefore, we should behave in a manner that does not cause concern.

If the officer behaves in an unprofessional manner, file a report after the fact, but don't be stupid and put yourself in jeopardy in the heat of the moment.

posted by True Freedom on 3/12/14 @ 12:47 p.m.

True Freedom;

Yes, I'm not a young person, I've been to many countries where police forces don't play nice, and I do realize that anybody confronting a bully with a gun and an attitude requires slow deliberate movement and speech.

Even so, I will still not degrade myself or scrape and tap-dance to appease his/her secret inferiority complex. Indeed, I have survived my anarchy-complex. But many more young people (of all colors) will not because America's police-state IS getting worse.


posted by DanD on 3/15/14 @ 05:07 p.m.
Post A Comment

Requires free registration.

(Forgotten your password?")